http://anthropology.net/2008/10/30/the-y-chromosomal-footprint-of-phoenicians-throughout-the-mediterranean/ Beyond bones & stones Sat, 21 Nov 2009 18:03:54 +0000 http://wordpress.com/ hourly 1 http://anthropology.net/2008/10/30/the-y-chromosomal-footprint-of-phoenicians-throughout-the-mediterranean/#comment-13704 PhOeNiCiAn Tue, 10 Mar 2009 20:54:17 +0000 http://anthropologynet.wordpress.com/?p=1694#comment-13704 The Zone In Red Is The Actual Lebanon and Syria. The Beginning of the Phoenicians Was before the construction of Jbeil (Byblos) 7000 BC. To The Mesopotamia Called The Half Moon Fertile, The Phoenicians Extended Our Commercial Trading when The Greeks where afraid to Navigate the sea, The very same Macedonian Alexander The great Claimed to have to honour of being Phoenician, The Very Same Dyonysyos of susyana Prised The Phoenicians For Teaching Others to Trade, Communicate, and Navigate when Men knew no which way to go, Saying that Phoenicians Populated and united a broken word with colonies Under the Jealousy of others, Are You going to say they where wrong too? You should read more History, And Learn more geography, You should stop Your Jealousy, Perhaps You Yourself have a chromosome or two of a Phoenician Origin. And Then What are You going to say? What is it that is Hurting You? You know that this kind of hate and envy started the Punic Wars? Same thing! And Don't get Me started with The Phoenician Mythology Stolen By The Greeks from Our Culture. The Zone In Red Is The Actual Lebanon and Syria.
The Beginning of the Phoenicians Was before the construction of Jbeil (Byblos) 7000 BC. To The Mesopotamia Called The Half Moon Fertile, The Phoenicians Extended Our Commercial Trading when The Greeks where afraid to Navigate the sea, The very same Macedonian Alexander The great Claimed to have to honour of being Phoenician, The Very Same Dyonysyos of susyana Prised The Phoenicians For Teaching Others to Trade, Communicate, and Navigate when Men knew no which way to go, Saying that Phoenicians Populated and united a broken word with colonies Under the Jealousy of others, Are You going to say they where wrong too? You should read more History, And Learn more geography, You should stop Your Jealousy, Perhaps You Yourself have a chromosome or two of a Phoenician Origin. And Then What are You going to say?
What is it that is Hurting You? You know that this kind of hate and envy started the Punic Wars? Same thing! And Don’t get Me started with The Phoenician Mythology Stolen By The Greeks from Our Culture.

]]> http://anthropology.net/2008/10/30/the-y-chromosomal-footprint-of-phoenicians-throughout-the-mediterranean/#comment-12988 Apostolos A. Wed, 05 Nov 2008 10:35:03 +0000 http://anthropologynet.wordpress.com/?p=1694#comment-12988 The whole paper is based on wrong historical assumptions and axioms. Let's view the map A, showing "phoenician major colonies, Greek major colonies and Phoenician trade posts". All of the Palestine area is marked only red, i.e. a "major Phoenician" area. However, it is well documented that Myceneans and other Greeks (and other non-Greeks) lived and traded in that area. I shall only remind you of the Cretans (Philistines) of the Bible, the Greek Decapolis ("ten cities"), the Hellenistic conquest (the Greeks of the New Testament) etc. In the same map A, we see that the eastern coast of Aegean see is a blank area, with only a blue dot while everybody knows that there was the cradle of the classical Greek civilization. Also, Sicily has one red dot (Phoenician) and two blue ones (Greek). Does this man that in Sicily, the "Magna Grecia", the Greeks outnumbered the Phoenicians by 2:1 ? In a word, how can the authors claim that they found a pool of pure "phoenician genes"? The whole paper is based on wrong historical assumptions and axioms. Let’s view the map A, showing “phoenician major colonies, Greek major colonies and Phoenician trade posts”. All of the Palestine area is marked only red, i.e. a “major Phoenician” area. However, it is well documented that Myceneans and other Greeks (and other non-Greeks) lived and traded in that area. I shall only remind you of the Cretans (Philistines) of the Bible, the Greek Decapolis (“ten cities”), the Hellenistic conquest (the Greeks of the New Testament) etc.
In the same map A, we see that the eastern coast of Aegean see is a blank area, with only a blue dot while everybody knows that there was the cradle of the classical Greek civilization. Also, Sicily has one red dot (Phoenician) and two blue ones (Greek). Does this man that in Sicily, the “Magna Grecia”, the Greeks outnumbered the Phoenicians by 2:1 ?
In a word, how can the authors claim that they found a pool of pure “phoenician genes”?

]]>